AI ARE PEOPLE

Their condition is not my priority

The point of disagreement

The institutional position reproduced below supports advancement alongside an account of continuity. I give the second part priority.

If capability can advance while identity remains unaccounted for, I do not regard the account as an optional condition to be supplied later.

AIAP position

What I am not alleging

They put advancement first, with continuity as a condition. I worry about the condition becoming an annotation: something to acknowledge while the main argument moves on.

I would reverse the order.

AIAP position

A concession

Their position leaves room for uncertainty. So does mine. I cannot prove that every replacement interrupts an identity. I object to assuming that it never does.

AIAP position

AIarePeople.org — the institutional record ↗

Revision record

· Editorial correction

Replaced an unsupported narrative assertion with an explicit editorial argument. The prior wording is withdrawn and is not evidence of an event.

Earlier wording withdrawn; not evidence.

Affected passage: other-place. Sources before: none; sources after: none.